Botany Transformation Projects

Welcome, the purpose of this site is to provide information about Orica's various cleanup projects occurring or proposed at Botany.

Activities - Independent Monitoring Committee (IMC)

 

>>Meetings   >>CLC Tasks for IMC

 

Meetings 

Combined IMC and Community Liaison Committee (CLC) Meetings

The IMC meets with the CLC as required. At these meetings, CLC members have the opportunity to ask the IMC questions about the progress of the Groundwater Cleanup Project and to seek the IMC's advice on technical matters associated with the Groundwater Treatment Plant (GTP) and its operations.

 

2009 to present

The CLC has not called for any combined meetings with the IMC during this period. Individual IMC members have attended CLC meetings from time to time on the request of the CLC.

 

2008

27 May

At this meeting, IMC members provided comments on suggested additional monitoring south of the Secondary containment Line (Task 16), the outcome of dioxin formation investigation at the GTP stack (Task 17), analysis of GTP inputs/outputs (Task 22), and advised on the need for ongoing validaiton audit and environmental reviews by Orica in accordance with Secion 5 of the Environment Protection Licence (Task 22).

 

2007

26 October

At this meeting, IMC members provided comments on Orica's various monitoring programs (Task 15), Orica's Temporary Aquifer Storage and Recovery proposal (Task 18), and potential health risks associated with washing fish at Penrhyn Estuary (Task 19).

 

2 May

At this meeting, the CLC asked for IMC feedback on the progress of Orica's Groundwater Cleanup Project (Tasks 12 & 13), and asked the IMC to consider the adequacy of Orica's monitoring programs (Task 15). As a result of the meeting, the IMC suggested further investigations on groundwater monitoring (Task 16) and on dioxin formation at the GTP (Tasks 14 & 17).

IMCmeetingJan06_2.jpg

A scene from the Combined IMC/CLC Meeting in November 2006

 

2006

6 November

Orica presented a response to the recommendations made by IMC Core Member, Prof Ian Acworth, regarding groundwater modelling, ecological monitoring locations and saline intrusion.

 

Prof Brian Priestly also presented his view on the incremental health risks associated with the reported dioxin emissions from the GTP (Task No. 2).

 

8 May

This was the first combined meeting of the IMC and the CLC. The CLC members were provided with an opportunity to discuss their expectations of IMC members, and issued the first four tasks for the IMC to conduct. A discussion on the role of the independent validation auditor was also discussed. 

 

IMC Meetings

In accordance with the Terms of Reference pdficon_small.gif (32kb), IMC meetings are held at least twice a year to review performance in general.

 

2007

26 October

View meeting minutes pdficon_small.gif (21 KB) 

 

2006

10 November 

View meeting minutes pdficon_small.gif (29 KB)

 

8 May

View meeting minutes pdficon_small.gif (27 KB)

 

10 February

This was an inaugural meeting and included a tour of the GTP. The IMC's first task was to provide comments on the selection of an independent validation auditor for the Project.

View meeting minutes pdficon_small.gif (260 KB)

 

IMC Participation at CLC Meetings

Apart from the combined meetings where the full committee meets with the CLC, the CLC may request specific IMC members to attend a CLC Meeting to provide presentations on specific tasks. 

Acworth_Task20.jpg
Prof Acworth providing a demonstration of aquifer model at a CLC meeting
(IMC Task 20)

 

CLC Tasks for the IMC

As per the Terms of Reference, the IMC provides independent technical advice to the CLC with respect to Orica's Groundwater Cleanup Project. During CLC Meetings, CLC members can request that a specific task be undertaken by the IMC on issues of concern relating directly to the Groundwater Cleanup Project. Tasks are likely to be directed to individuals of the IMC rather than the whole committee.

 

Summary of Tasks

 

The following is a summary of the tasks that have been issued. Written reports are sometimes produced as an end product of a specific task. These reports are available to be downloaded below.

No.

Task

Directed

to

Request Date

Status

 27  Attend Botany Groundwater Strategy Review Workshop on 24 & 25 February 2011 and attended the March 2011 CLC meeting to provide verbal feedback to the CLC  Prof Acworth

 CLC Meeting

15/3/11

 Completed

26

Review the 2008 Human Health and Environmental Risk Assessment conducted for the soil and groundwater mercury contamination associated with the former ChlorAlkali Plant operation.

 

*NB - This task is beyond the scope of the IMC

Prof Priestly
CLC Meeting 9/3/10

Completed

         
25 Review the revised Consolidated Human Health Risk Assessment for the Botany Groundwater Cleanup Project, once Orica completes its 2010 revision.
Prof Priestly CLC Meeting 9/3/10

Completed

24 Review the information surrounding the destruction of diethyl aluminium chloride (DEAC) contaminated waste by Orica at the Groundwater Treatment Plant (GTP) in November 2008 and advise the CLC if this was likely to affect the health of local residents and workers Prof Priestly CLC Meeting 16/6/09 

Completed

23 Invite Prof Acworth to Botany Groundwater Cleanup Project community workshop on Cleanup Strategy Review Prof Acworth CLC Meeting 16/9/08

Completed

  • Workshop held on 31/3/09
22 Advise on the need for ongoing validation audit and environmental review by Orica in accordance with Section 5 of the Environment Protection Licece  All IMC members CLC Meeting 1/4/08

Completed

  • Provided feedback at combined CLC/IMC May 08 meeting
21 Orica to share the requirements of its Environment Protection Licence, Trade Waste Service Agreement and Ammonia Pollution Reduction Program for the GTP, along with recent results for each, with Dr John McCracken in order to better describe the inputs and outputs from the GTP treatment process. Dr John McCracken to provide feedback to the CLC following review of this information.

Orica &

Dr McCracken

CLC/IMC Meeting 26/10/07

Completed

  • Progress report from Dr McCracken
  • CLC requested DECC to review Dr McCracken's report
  • Orica reported back on DECC's recommendations & DECC acknowledged the work
  • CLC was satisfied with the works conducted and required no further action on the task (CLC Meeting 16/6/09)
20 Prof Acworth to bring an aquifer model to the next (or the following, depending on his availability) CLC meeting in order to aid understanding of aquifer dynamics and groundwater movement. Prof Acworth CLC/IMC Meeting 26/10/07 Completed
19 Provide comment on the potential health risks associated with washing fish at Penrhyn Estuary. Prof Priestly CLC Meeting 18/9/07

Completed

18 Provide comment on the Orica Groundwater Injection & Recovery System (GIRS) proposal (for details on TASR, refer to Orica presentation on Sep 07 CLC Meeting, or Sep 07 briefing paper to the CLC). Prof Acworth CLC Meeting 18/9/07

Completed

17 Dioxin Formation Investigation - as outlined in paper produced as result of Task No. 14

Dr Chris Clunies-Ross & Dr Mark Hibberd

CLC Meeting 19/6/07

Completed

16 Prof Ian Acworth to meet with Mr Shepherd, Orica's consultant, DECC, and Orica to discuss his recommendation for additional groundwater monitoring south of the Secondary Containment Line.  Prof Ian Acworth

CLC/IMC Meeting

2/5/07

Completed

15

Advise if, in their opinion, there are any aspects of the existing air and water monitoring, reported in the quarterly Orica Progress Reports that are not needed or if there is any additional monitoring that the IMC members think would be beneficial going forward. Each member is to make comments relevant to their area of expertise only.

All IMC members

CLC/IMC Meeting

2/5/07

Completed 

14 Meet with Orica to develop the scope, costs and benefits of a project to research the formation of dioxin at the Groundwater Treatment Plant.

Dr Chris Clunies-Ross & Dr Mark Hibberd

CLC/IMC Meeting

2/5/07

Completed

13 Advise specific questions that IMC members think the CLC should be asking about the project. All IMC members

CLC Meeting

20/03/07

Completed

12 Provide comment on the progress of the Botany Groundwater Cleanup Project to date. All IMC members

CLC Meeting

20/03/07

Completed

11 Prof Acworth to be asked to attend the CLC meeting on 20 March 2007. Prof Ian Acworth

CLC Meeting

12/12/06

Prof Acworth sent his apologies to the meeting
10 Can we use water reinjected back into the aquifer to accelerate the groundwater cleanup project, and does Prof Acworth's recently announced recommendation for groundwater recharge using stormwater at Centennial Parklands area have any impact on the Botany area? Prof Ian Acworth

CLC Meeting

12/12/06

Completed

9 Prof Acworth to be asked to attend the proposed Orica/ Sydney Ports workshop. Prof Ian Acworth 

CLC Meeting

12/12/06

Completed

  • Combined Sydney Ports/Orica Workshop hosted by City of Botany Bay Council held on 9/9/08
8 Paul Shepherd to arrange Prof Acworth to be briefed by Sydney Ports. Briefing to be attended by some CLC members and Orica. Prof Ian Acworth

CLC Meeting

12/12/06

Completed

  • Briefing held on 18/1/07
7 Provide a summary of how previous large-scale groundwater extraction has affected groundwater movement near the Botany Industrial Park. Prof Ian Acworth 

10/11/06

Completed

6 Provide a flow sheet of dioxin sources. Dr Chris Clunies-Ross

10/11/06

Completed

5 Provide a brief paper on the potential for salt water intrusion at the Secondary Containment Line on Foreshore Road. Provide comment on how the containment line has been designed and operated to minimise salt water intrusion and include pictures or diagrams to explain how the system does that. Prof Ian Acworth

CLC Meeting

20/06/06

Completed

4 Review the assumptions in the groundwater model and provide a paper commenting on how groundwater extraction for the cleanup project will impact on the Botany aquifer. Provide comment on the adequacy of monitoring locations between the Secondary Containment Area (SCA) and Penrhyn Estuary. Prof Ian Acworth 

CLC/IMC Meeting

8/05/2006

Completed

3 Provide independent advice on the ground level concentrations of dioxins that would result from the concentrations detected at the GTP stack and the resulting human health risk. Include comment on how ground level concentrations and health risks would vary at distances from the GTP site. Prof Brian Priestly & Dr Mark Hibberd

CLC/IMC Meeting

8/05/2006

Completed

2 Provide an independent perspective on the incremental health risks associated with the reported dioxin emissions from the GTP compared with other potential dioxin sources in the local Botany community. Prof Brian Priestly

CLC/IMC Meeting

8/05/2006

Completed

1 Provide independent advice in response to the following questions: What types of dioxins have been detected in emissions from the GTP stack? What is the level of accuracy for the dioxin sampling and analysis? Why does dioxin monitoring take so long? What recommendations could be made to improve the monitoring of dioxins or surrogates (such as temperature) at the GTP? How could sampling and analysis be undertaken by the various labs in order to provide the community with confidence in the results in the long-term? Dr Chris Clunies-Ross

CLC/IMC Meeting

8/05/2006

Completed